hand crafted

Firefly Farms 20 Year Seal
Firefly Farms Seal

Who’s ready to eat?

Shop Our Cheeses

That cheese drawer in your fridge? It’s about to get a huge upgrade.

Anita L
Read More
My order shipped overnight the same day as I ordered! Everything was fresh and tasty, just as I remembered their cheeses! Thank you Firefly Farms for living up to my expectations!
Melaney H
Read More
Everything I get – every time, is top notch! The quality and freshness are undeniable! Thank you!
Jean Yves-Courtois
Read More
Probably the best American cheese we have eaten to date since we moved from France 4 years ago. No surprise they have won prestigious awards for this divine cheese.
Read More
The best cheese ever in the US. People are friendly and very knowledgeable. The Deep Creek Market is a must-see if you are 50 miles radius around. I will now order online since I am not living in this area.
Joann Devanko
Read More
If there were more stars I would color them all.
Jane C
Read More
My favorite, I give as gifts the comments are WOW where can I get it. I do tell them!
Marilyn Seneff
Read More

Happy goats

Happy People

Not all milk is created equal. We work with local farmers to create fair pricing, long-term sustainability, and most important of all, happy goats and cows whose milk makes for delicious cheese and a thriving local economy.

Stay Fresh

Give us your email, we’ll give you good stuff.

(And no spammy stuff. Promise.)

Stop in.

FireFly Farms Market

Mind blown.

Our awesome goat and cows’ milk cheeses, gourmet items, locally made gifts, and more. Order a cheese platter, book a pairing, shop our wine selection, and enjoy a coffee and panini at our café. All the while, learn about the cheese made in our creamery only a few blocks away!

Deep Creek Lake

This is how the

Magic Happens

People are often amazed that all of our cheeses are made with just four simple ingredients—plus one secret ingredient. You.

    Your Cart
    Your cart is emptyReturn to Shop