Fast, safe, and sustainable

How We Ship

We take as much care in shipping our cheese as we do in making it. That’s why we ship all orders with two-day shipping via FedEx using biodegradable packaging and eco-friendly ice packs. All orders ship on Tuesdays and Wednesdays. Once you input your shipping address, you’ll see available shipping options and rates.

You place an Order

As soon as you place an order on our website, we start planning delivery. Orders ship twice a week, on Tuesdays and Wednesdays, excluding holidays. So, if you place an order Tuesday by midnight (Eastern Time), it will ship Wednesday morning. Orders placed over the weekend ship Tuesday.

On the Way

Once your order leaves the creamery, we’ll automatically email you a FedEx tracking number you can use to watch your package in real time. If you don’t see the email, check your spam folder! In the meantime, you can prepare your cheese drawer and browse our recipes for inspiration!


When you receive the box, open it as soon as possible and (unless you are going to eat the cheese immediately) store the contents in the fridge. Take pictures, and don’t forget to tag us on Instgram! The insulated packaging can be recycled or composted, along with the box. Re-use the ice pack as many times as you like: it’s non-toxic!

Firefly Farms Seal

Leading in sustainability

Cutting Edge Packaging

We want you to enjoy our cheese in the comfort of your home, but we know that plastic packaging and styrofoam insulation are terrible for the planet, so we decided to go a different route. The packaging we use is sourced from Nature Packand made using renewable plant starches and plant oils. The insulation can be recycled or composted (it can even biodegrade in fresh or salt water without harming marine life). The gel pack is water soluble and non-toxic.  

"Everything was fresh and tasty, just as I remembered their cheeses! Thank you FireFly Farms for living up to my expectations!"