Cheese Club

If you’re someone who loves FireFly, always needs cheese in the fridge, and wants a culinary journey that takes you to exciting places, join the FireFly Cheese Club! Every month you’ll enjoy a selection of cheeses and pairings delivered to your doorstep, along with expert guidance from our mongers. This is your chance to sample the full array of FireFly cheeses, be the first to taste new products, and get exclusive goodies that we don’t carry in-store or online. You’ll also benefit from exclusive member perks and a members-only newsletter with more behind-the-scenes info from the creamery and from other producers we feature.

Firefly Farms Seal

more than just a club

Hand Selected

Each month’s box includes three cheeses from FireFly Farms and other producers, along with pairings (jams, nuts, dried fruit) and crackers. Past months have featured our Merry Goat Round, a wedge of Cabra la Mancha, Thomasville Tomme, a sweet piece of real honeycomb, lime and saffron almonds, and olive oil crisps. January’s cheese club will include a  mini-wheel of our cow’s milk Bloomy Breeze, White Rock aged goat’s cheese, Irish porter cheddar, a cherry chai jam, dried blood orange slices, and Nettle & Honey crackers from Frog Hollow Farmstead.

Cheese Board in a Box

Manufacturing Icon

sustainable shipping

We take as much care in shipping our cheese as we do in making it. That’s why we ship all orders with two-day shipping via FedEx using biodegradable packaging and eco-friendly ice packs. 

Leaving town for a month? Fridge already stuffed? No matter the reason, it’s easy to pause your subscription for as long as you need, via your FireFly account.


  • Exclusive products not otherwise available for purchase
  • Member Appreciation Month (20% off sitewide)
  • Your very own FireFly branded cheese notebook, where you can take notes on all your favorite cheeses and pairings
  • Member merch, like t-shirts and stickers
  • Monthly newsletter with behind-the-scenes content about FireFly and the producers we feature